September evaluation - top editors, competition winners, newsletter [Archive] - SoccerVista

View Full Version : September evaluation - top editors, competition winners, newsletter

Radek

10-04-2007, 11:18 AM

Hallo!

first easy one - competition September 2007 round

1. laurentiucinca 60 EUR
2. dan45 40 EUR
3. deti 30 EUR

October round is ready, participation is free. So have fun! - http://www.soccervista.com/competition/

Top editors - September 2007

After reading all options I choosed:
Hiyavata, Xtremer111, Beli, catalinho07, hunt3r and zigoto all 30 EUR.

Top newsletter contributors - August 2007

Xazar7a 30 EUR
Beli 30 EUR
TONNY 30 EUR

Congratulations! Of course I will continue to send weekly newsletter and everybody has chance to be co-autor. Just send me email to castka@gmail.com with „Weekly picks“ in subject.

conditions:
1.Some brief analyses have to be included with picks.
2.Must be betting picks for weekend.
3.Must be send till Thursday midnight.

You can subscribe to newsletter here (http://www.soccervista.com/history.php)

Thread closed. Congratulations to all!

finchy

10-04-2007, 01:26 PM

I pay tribute to zigoto, who has a stunning success rate and really deserves a prize!
Not to be too self-confident, I think that I provide useful information sometimes, too.
Xazar7a is on level as before.
catalinho too.

this is my personal opinion :)

And no offence but I don't find it intriguing when picks only are posted..

catalinho07

10-04-2007, 01:30 PM

Beli

10-04-2007, 01:43 PM

I canot say names here everyone did good, but i would like first to see result of everyone i mean how many picks he post and how many he was right then if there is doubt between tipsters you can see who post beter analyses i mean beter information for pick not only "i think it is home win or away win or meybe say i feel that it will be home or away win or i hear voice from inside of me" thats bad.I canot say names i dont see it reasonable writing names here we all know who post picks here so no offence for noone all contribute for that, best to choose is if you look result to all meybe it will need time for you but i think that results would be more real.

i would like to thankx all who post here and i hope in the future we will have more users on forum and beter results.

TONNY

10-04-2007, 08:11 PM

I did very well in the first half of the month with a series of winning picks + analysis consecutively. But then I was very very busy with family matters and viists and posted less picks ...

I would mention HUnt3r, Beli and Xtremer11

Tonny

Shantia

10-04-2007, 08:58 PM

I would mention Hunt3r ,Xtremer11 and Zigoto...GL boys

Hylander

10-05-2007, 12:35 PM

I don't know what to say...I really think that zigoto had a nice run with good picks and also good analysis in the portuguese league. The others where equal imo..with good picks and analysis one week,not that good the next week.It's really hard to name some winners...Anyway,I'm sure you will award the ones who deserve.

hunt3r

10-06-2007, 09:10 AM

i would suggest adrian and tonny

I whis you all the best!

tini070

10-06-2007, 10:28 AM

1.Xazar7a
2.Beli
3.TONNY
4.catalinho07 (he is Ok but he predictes only games with whery low odds....)

HiyaVata

10-06-2007, 10:40 AM

Radek, what is your criteria to a good predictor? Tell us this and then we'll be able to evaluate and choose your picks for the month.

mariusrec

10-06-2007, 12:10 PM

Beli and HiyaVata had good picks last month...

INs0mNIaK

10-06-2007, 03:58 PM

I'm watching you for a while now .. I really like the predictions of catalinho07, he's doing a great job (no big odds but kind of safe bets) .

Radek

10-06-2007, 05:44 PM

what is your criteria to a good predictor?

Good predictor (moderator) is reason why people visiting this forum.

If many users say I'm here to read "MrX" picks - he is good moderator for me.

There is no rules to become "good" moderator.

lumeci

10-06-2007, 07:36 PM

hi everyone, I think that catalinho's picks are the best, and for the moment he is the best in socecrvista

bye

finchy

10-07-2007, 10:35 AM

Yes yes, the easiest way is to register 2-3 accounts and post a short reply with them. Same as polls.
Some people do it, obviously.

Xazar7a

10-07-2007, 10:47 AM

Yes it is really hard to choose the best, because i am sure everybody try to be helpful. Radek I understand why you start this poll but it think it is better like before you to choose the best editors, because as Finchy marked some people can make more accounts and vote.
But After all i will give my vote: i think Finchy have good analysis, Xtremer11 too, and maybe Zigoto.

Thats from me

Best wishes to everyone :)

adrian

10-07-2007, 01:39 PM

It's hard to tell who are the best here. I think everyone tried to be usefull...I'm sure that u'll find the best, Radek...

xtremer11

10-07-2007, 02:28 PM

everybody did a great job, i don't know how will Radek choose the best, but i'll go for Xazarta and zigoto maybe

froment

10-07-2007, 02:46 PM

Hello
I have been watching the picks from the beginning of new forum, and IMO Hylander offers the best picks; not a lot of them, and not with high odds, but very reliable. After him, I often take the proposals of Hunt3r, Zigoto, Catalinho07, Shantia and Mariusrec. Anyway, all the others are also helpful, so thanks to all and keep with this good work!

catalinho07

10-08-2007, 02:19 PM

So RADEK have you made up your mind?

TyCoKiA

10-08-2007, 02:35 PM

lumeci and INs0mNIaK seems to be the same person.. one with 1 post and one with 3 posts, posting with the same purpose.. honestly said, i don't think catalinho performed well on september.. Radek, maybe u shld only look at those whose posts number is more than 10 and not those like lumeci and INs0mNIaK (most probably the same person) coming to say "hi everyone, I think that catalinho's picks are the best, and for the moment he is the best in socecrvista

bye". Thats kinda stupid...

catalinho07

10-08-2007, 02:45 PM

TyCoKiA

10-08-2007, 03:24 PM

lol ... if you don't know you should shut up... lumeci is at soccervista before me and you and he had many analyses on old soccervista blog...

o.0 ok i didn't know it then. But why must u be so agitated. IF u cant accept comments from others how can u be a tipters? Do you dare to say that u did well during september?

catalinho07

10-08-2007, 03:31 PM

o.0 ok i didn't know it then. But why must u be so agitated. IF u cant accept comments from others how can u be a tipters? Do you dare to say that u did well during september?

I felt offended by your comment not because you said that I didn't do well in september.

And yes I had some winnings and some loosings in september (but more winners than loosers)...you can't just always win and when I loose I try to provide with more analysis to win again... so yes I think I did well in september but not the best month. Also look on the first pages of my thread with picks and look what the users said and you could also see the picks ;)

but let's not spam this topic we can talk on private or on msn/yahoo.

hunt3r

10-08-2007, 07:56 PM

all this fighting for 40 euro.. and i reffer to catalinho only , i dont understand u..maybe radek will not give nothing this month..maybe that will teach u a lesson !! i hope u read this radek !

zigoto

10-08-2007, 08:03 PM

Over and out

Sorry my friends, I was writing my picks for today games but then I saw that even I got this records last month:

http://forum.bettingadvice.com//viewtopic.php?p=1703787#1703787
http://forum.bettingadvice.com//viewtopic.php?p=1717279#1717279
http://forum.bettingadvice.com//viewtopic.php?p=1753178#1753178
http://forum.bettingadvice.com//viewtopic.php?p=1757692#1757692

(sorry the external links but its easier to find the links there)

And even I got some of the most viewed topics last month and the most visited this week...

And even I got 5 other moderators saying I should won, Radek prefered to take the usual moderators that always win... COngratulations for the ones that win for 5 months in a row and show me where they did better...

No more picks here, I hate unfair things...

all this fighting for 40 euro.. and i reffer to catalinho only , i dont understand u..maybe radek will not give nothing this month..maybe that will teach u a lesson !! i hope u read this radek !

Its better to dont give nothing, than to give something and be unfair...

Radek

10-08-2007, 08:42 PM

What to say...

It's exactly I don't want...

My budged for newsletter and moderators is 250-300 Eur per month. I really trying to be fair. I don't know anybody from you personally.

My idea were to make nice forum, where everybody will share their ideas about soccer games and trying to beat bookmakers.

This month I will add hunt3r and zigoto to winners.
But next month I have to make some system. Any ideas appreciated.

Sorry for my English.

zigoto

10-08-2007, 08:52 PM

Radek

10-08-2007, 08:56 PM

Maybe straight votation allowed only for people with more than 10 posts for example, to avoid possible clones...

Yes that sounds good. Or I will create special section only for moderators and only moderators will vote. Just idea.

adrian

10-08-2007, 09:06 PM

we started so good... too bad...I really care for this site...too bad...

Xazar7a

10-08-2007, 09:15 PM

I think here must have any rules. It is right that some people here write only for the money. But this is not the right way, i think the most important thing is to help to all the people. When i was younger and when i know less for the football i used to read analysis and picks with the hope this predictions are valuable and the people really think what they have written. I improved myself in that way and now i write analysis and hope that i will be helpful, because that is the thing i had wanted before from the other people like me. I think everybody here, all the moderators should know that, not to write a post because they didnt write any pick today, but because they know and really trust in that they write. I think the winner should not be chosen because he wrote 50 post this month, but because for example he wrote 10 but valuable. Not post like : 1,2 sentences and a pick, but some valuable info for the match: squads, injuries, players. I think this is important and everybody should know that, if you dont have much info better dont write, but it is up to you. I think there will be not big change after all, but i hope some people will understand me.
About the voting: Radek, with all my admirations to you i think you should chose the winner, you are the administrator and this should be your decision. I understand you about the voting because you in your point of view want to know is this useful and that if the people like it, and that is good, but some people only spam here with more accounts in order to get votes that they dont deserve. I remember the first time i win here in the old blog. it was great month for me, very good predictions and analysis(i wont be modest about that) and i was was in almost every vote from the users, and that was because my analysis were good and i did well all the month. Before there was fake voting too and this problem is hard to be solved. Zigoto offer that the user who can vote to have 10 post, but i dont think it is the way, because i easily can create account and post 10 post for a few minutes. So i think a decision can be to make some kind of polls in this forum which ask all the visitors questions about the site, what they think about the forum, about the pick and all the things here. But i dont know in moment exactly how this can work in the best way.
And one last thing I think it is good that you Radek added Zigoto to the winners, he really deserves a prize for his good work here, but i think there are another people who also deserves a prize and now they will feel damaged.
Radek i hope you understand me in the right way!

With all my good feelings to everyone here, i wish you all the best, and good luck mates, because you know it is the most important thing!!!

Shantia

10-08-2007, 09:24 PM

its good your decision Radek..... zigoto and hunt3r add to win.....

hunt3r

10-08-2007, 09:40 PM

thank you radek.. whit zigoto u did the right thing, i care more about the forum than that money.. thanks for encouragement and i hope next month will be better at predictions !! good luck all for the next tips !

finchy

10-08-2007, 10:45 PM

But "unlike all of you" I care about the money, and for the money only(oh it sounds so nice when you say "i care about the site, i don't give a shit about the money", i just melt! :D)
And who cares about the site, will know that it's not appropriate when people post something like:

"combo for saturday:
milan - catania 1
barcelona - levante 1
derby - chelsea 2
enjoy!"

this is ridicilous to me, and i don't really mind if some of you curses me or not.
i quit writing for this site, i don't know whether someone cares, but i think that this site does not deserve my effort.
it's an insult for me, that people who post just 3 picks with no explanation win the prizes, and i get nothing. Or people who don't know what the fuck English is and write in Cambogian with latin letters and some wrongly spelled english words from time to time.
And I'd understand it if they had way way more ROI than me, but they do not.

I tried to offer some unstandart picks, not so obvious, something a little bit different - a view on English football. I made it in an understandable and argumented way, but obviously no one notices. But I have the self-confidence that I did relatively well and I really don't care if somebody says "since people don't notice it, you're not worthy".
This is not the case, to my mind.

So what's the conclusion?
Have fun with your 3 word picks on 1.30-1.40 odds,
I don't want to waste my time anymore here.

(P.S Of course I don't refer to everybody in the forum.)

hunt3r

10-08-2007, 11:11 PM

why are u so angry finchy? i dont understand u ..is all about the money ?? dont u care anything else?

Xazar7a

10-08-2007, 11:32 PM

all this fighting for 40 euro.. and i reffer to catalinho only , i dont understand u..maybe radek will not give nothing this month..maybe that will teach u a lesson !! i hope u read this radek !

You get yours man, leave him alone! I think he have a reason, he really writes good and interesting articles and i think he is also one of these who deserves a prize, he not only write picks but and analysis on different, from all here, point of view. Hope understand me.

catalinho07

10-09-2007, 06:45 AM

I really don't get you hunter? Isn't this about the prize that top editors will win? Of course I needed the money so much and stayed on this site much more than you and wrote thousands of game and I wanted to win surely. Of course I care about the site the main thing is to help the others with winning picks but money is money and who deserved it, took it...

OK NO REASON TO WRITE IN THIS WE WILL ONLY ARGUE, the winners were posted there a new month is coming, get back to your analysis! :D

finchy

10-09-2007, 01:34 PM

why are u so angry finchy? i dont understand u ..is all about the money ?? dont u care anything else?

Know why I am angry?
No offence to you, of course I have nothing personal against you - but to cut the long story short, I think that I did more for this site than you and some of the other winners did.
And in the end I get nothing.
That's why I'm angry, is it clear now?

Because when one makes effort to do something - expects something in return. That's the way a normal human being regards things.

But OK it's over now - good luck in October.

xtremer11

10-09-2007, 02:17 PM

Of course everybody who won will welcome their money and use them. But catalinho, you should understand that when you are writing all for this 40 euro, most of the people who read the analyses here bet more than 40 E on a single bet. And this is for everybody: Try to post analyses when you know smth for the game - injuries, squad, form, play. Not just writing post, with the only reason to have some and to win the ******* prizes. Like finchy was doing for example, he knew the English league and gives analyses for English games.